Paganism and a Crisis of Faith
I have been absent from my blog and from Pagan circles in general for the last 2 months. I experienced a veritable crisis of faith concerning Paganism. I began to ask myself what the hell I was doing in Paganism and what it really had to offer me? Paganism was wonderful for celebrating the cyclical changes in the macrocosm and the microcosm, for attuning and connecting to the Earth Mother, for establishing a framework of interconnectivity and sacrality amongst all life, and for the performance of magic. Something seemed to be missing, though. I was in a boat in the middle of the ocean, lost without a rudder or a compass, and desperately trying to find a way back to myself. In these times of personal crisis (divorce, loss of a loved one, financial loss, etc.), I was looking for an anchor, some spiritual teaching or practice to help me find my way. Celebrating the sabbats and honoring the earth are wonderful practices, but they aren’t designed to help me navigate the monsoon of a mid-life crisis. Magic is a wonderful and powerful tool, but if I am operating from a place of emptiness – a place where self-love, self-knowledge, and self-acceptance are in doubt – then magic will not help me reclaim those parts of myself because personal power is a pre-requisite of magic! Knowing that I am Divine on a cognitive level is wonderful, but not being able embodying that in the experiential realm makes it little more than creative visualization.

Readers of my blog will be familiar with the flurry of posts regarding my journey into the realm of self-discovery. As I went deeper and deeper down the path of self-inquiry, I was saddened and dismayed by how little Paganism seemed to offer me in the way of self-knowledge and betterment. I was forced to turn to “The Work” of Byron Katie, to the shame and vulnerability research of Brene Brown, to books on self-love by Daphne Kingma and Gerald Jamposky, to books on the language of emotion by Karla McLaren, and to the meridian tapping techniques of EFT. These teachings, along with my own EMDR therapy, provided the guidance and support I needed to find myself and climb back out of the hole of self-despair. Should a religion be so self-contained as to provide the answers and tools needed to overcome personal crises or are we forced to look outside the bounds of our religion for help? In other words, is religion supposed to be a complete system of how our world works, what our purpose is, and how to live our lives within it or is it merely something to engage with when we are free of personal struggle and the need to find ourselves?
I recall being at a public Beltane celebration in my area recently and watching the ritual participants wave their hands in exotic gestures, repeat tired incantations, and perform a ceremony complete devoid of energy, life, or zeal. It was rote ritual, which I have begun to see more and more often. It all began to feel so empty to me. Sabbats, moons, magic ceremony – I felt like I was at a play rehearsing with beautiful props, but without the drama of a live performance.
What does Paganism have to offer the world? What does our religion bring that heals, empowers, and helps us overcome our life trauma to discover who and what we are? I am at a crossroads in life where I am uncertain whether I want to continue in Paganism or not. I feel that there is soooo much POTENTIAL in Paganism, but that, collectively, we have failed to actualize that potential. We have ritual, we have magic, and we have the outline of a philosophy….. What do you think? What does Paganism provide us as a people that allow us to dig deep, to find ourselves, to overcome personal adversity?
I sincerely welcome your responses. I want to believe that Paganism has teeth – that is capable of propelling us toward wholeness and completeness, but right now I’m in a boat in the middle of the ocean, waving a wand and watching the waves crash around me.


